Both land near 33 inches tall, but they represent two different philosophies: the 255/80R17 is the famous "skinny 33": narrow, tall, and superb in mud, snow, and ruts, while the 285/70R17 is a wider, more conventional 33 with a bigger contact patch for sand and rock. This comparison shows how their diameter and width trade off.

Use the live comparison above to see the exact diameter, circumference, revs/mile, and speedometer error between 255/80R17 and 285/70R17. Change either size to explore a different pairing, or open the full Tire Size calculator to start from scratch.